Bar

Search News
 Keywords
 Publish Date

(dd-mm-yyyy)

Categories
 ALL
 Criminal Defense News

 

Select a Category
Felonies
Information on some of the various felonies handled by the Law Office of Thomas P. Welch, Jr.

Misdemeanors
Information on some of the various Misdemeanors handled by the Law Office of Thomas P. Welch, Jr.

Forfeitures
What you need to know if the police seize your property.

Jackson Metro Area Courts
Locations for Jackson Metro Area Courtrooms.

Other Counties
Courtroom locations in other counties.


 

Announcements


No Announcement



Criminal Defense Information, News and Advice

 
Criminal Defense News
 Prev    Next

Emails are private?!
 Email To Friend    Print Version

The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals decided on December 14, 2010 that the government has to get a search warrant to get a person's email. 

 

 The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals held in United States of America v. Warshak on December 14, that a persons emails can not be seized by the government without a search warrant based on probable cause.  I'd like to paraphrase Mark Twain's quote and say  that "the death of the 4th Amendment has been greatly exaggerated"  but the Court held that since the government relied upon the Stored Communications Act of 1986, the warrantless seizure was ok under a good faith exception and the emails did not have to be excluded.

The government got Warshak's ISP to turn over all his emails, past and all future ones, without getting a search warrant.  The government relied upon the Stored Communications's Act, which when passed in 1986, had not contemplated email and the public's utter reliance upon it.  The 6th Circuit found email analogous to regular letters and said, "As we have discussed above, the police may not storm the postoffice and intercept a letter, and they are likewise forbidden from using the phone system to make a clandestine recording of a telephone call—unless they get a warrant, that is."  But since the SCA was there, the government relied upon it in good faith and thus the emails were not supressed.

One would hope that going forward, the government, in whatever manifestation it appears in, would have to get a search warrant to open mail, electronic or otherwise.



Powered by Comdev News Publisher

Announcements


No Announcement




Most Popular Questions

No FAQ Found